Podcasts Are up for Debate: Unpacking the Future of Podcasting

Podcasting is no longer a niche. It’s a cultural mainstay. Soaring audience numbers, emerging formats, and major cultural crossovers—podcasts have moved from the fringe into the mainstream. Its intimate and unfiltered origins catapulted the medium into must-have entertainment, with 55% of the US population ages 12 and up listening monthly. And with recent advancements and expansions, podcasts now compete with the scale and sophistication of other media.

Our latest podcast trends report, The Great Podcast Debate, explores this evolution, highlighting the most urgent questions shaping the future of the medium. Each debate presents two perspectives, informed by data and audience insights, to spark conversation and challenge assumptions.

Here’s a little peak at what you’ll find in the report.

The Video Shift

Up for debate: Is video killing the audio star?

The rise of video podcasts has reshaped how audiences consume content. While platforms like YouTube and TikTok are pushing visual storytelling to the forefront, many listeners still value podcasting’s original audio-first simplicity. This raises the question: Is video the future of podcasting or a distraction from its roots?

• All in on video: Video is transforming podcasting, creating parasocial connections and fueling monetization through visual formats. For younger audiences, video is the expectation rather than a bonus.

• Audio is the heart of podcasting: Audio’s intimacy, accessibility, and portability remain unmatched. For many, video adds unnecessary cost and complexity, while audio continues to deliver podcasting’s authentic appeal.

The Scale Myth

Up for debate: Does show size still matter?

Podcasts are both a mass and niche medium. While large shows attract advertisers with reach and celebrity power, smaller creators build passionate, loyal communities. So, should brands continue chasing audience size or embrace the outsized influence of more targeted audiences?

• Scale wins. Large shows deliver visibility and credibility for advertisers. Celebrity hosts and chart-topping podcasts provide built-in audiences and cross-platform influence.

• Niche is powerful. Niche creators cultivate deeper trust and engagement with listeners. Smaller shows, often hosted by everyday voices, may offer more authentic and lasting audience connections.

The Brand Gaze

Up for debate: Does brand safety help podcasting?

Advertisers want safety and consistency, but the safeguards that build trust can also stifle creativity. Brand safety tools open doors for investment, but strict standards may filter out diverse and unconventional voices. At the center of this debate: the balance between brand protection and creative freedom.

• Safety = Trust. Brand safety builds credibility, reassuring advertisers and driving long-term investment. Safeguards help podcasts align with mainstream expectations, making them competitive with traditional media.

• Filtering creativity. Excessive controls risk silencing underrepresented creators and muting bold content. And over-regulation may erode the very authenticity that make podcasting unique.

The AI Question

Up for debate: Is podcasting better in the AI age?

AI tools are transforming podcast production, editing, and advertising with speed and efficiency. While they promise opportunity and accessibility, they also risk erasing the human touch that makes podcasts distinct. So, we ask, does AI enhance or diminish the medium’s authenticity.

• AI is a tool. AI supports creators with smarter tools for editing, transcription, and distribution. For advertisers, it allows for fluid messaging and real-time customization.

• It flattens content. AI risks homogenizing voices and content. Listeners value human connection, honesty, and vulnerability—qualities AI cannot authentically replicate.

The Measurement Gap

Up for debate: Can the full impact of podcasts be measured?

Advertisers demand accountability, making measurement at critical issue. New analytics tools are closing gaps, but the medium’s open ecosystem, fragmented distribution, and consumer-driven listening behavior still present challenges. This raises the question: Can podcasts ever be fully measured, or is their deep influence inherently immeasurable?

• Ready to perform. Attribution and cross-platform analytics provide actionable data. With tools to track conversions and brand lift, podcasts are ready to prove ROI.

• Influence beyond clicks. Podcasting’s true influence—long-form storytelling, community-building, and cultural impact—extends beyond what numbers capture. Over emphasis on traditional metrics risk undervaluing the medium’s unique strengths.

One Thing Is Clear: Podcasts Inspire Passion

Podcasts are a cultural force, a medium for in-depth conversations, community building, and storytelling unlike any other. They offer a space where authenticity thrives, advertisers find value, and audiences connect in powerful, personal ways.

The passion the medium inspires has sparked growth and evolution as audiences and advertisers continue to flock to the space.

The SiriusXM Podcast Network: Undeniably Powerful

And that’s not up for debate.

We have #1 podcast network in the US with listeners 18 and up, with 70M podcast listeners, 2,500 shows, and more podcasts in the top 20 than any other network (that includes Spotify, iHeart, and Wondery). Our network combines the podcasts people can’t get enough of with the most beloved studios, creators, and hosts. And we’re constantly innovating to push the industry forward, giving brands the ability to reach audiences, build connections, and inspire action.

Let’s talk.

Get More from Podcast Advertising